Banned Books

About this Collection

Many of the works in the Online Library of Liberty have been banned or censored at various times by governments, established churches, and pubic schools for their content. This list has been compiled from the following sources:

Key People

Titles & Essays

THE READING ROOM

A Modified Proposal: The Man of Law’s Tale

By: Nathaniel Birzer

There is a third theme which weaves its way through the first few of Chaucer’s The Canterbury Tales, building up to its use in one of the most famous Tales, the Wife of Bath’s Tale. This is the theme of a good woman.

THE READING ROOM

A Proposition Critiqued: The Miller’s Tale

By: Nathaniel Birzer

An earlier post explored the rigorous ‘dialogue’ elicited by the Knight’s Tale between the other pilgrims. The Miller is the first to push back, using a two-pronged attack against the ideas of high philosophy and courtly romance in…
The Advancement of Learning

Sir Francis Bacon (author)

The first of Bacon’s writings on the nature of science and the scientific method. He also had a view of the unity of knowledge, both scientific and non-scientific.

The Analects

Confucius (author)

A 1,000 page book which includes the original Chinese text, a translation, and commentaries.

Areopagitica (1644) (Jebb ed.)

John Milton (author)

This is Milton’s famous defense of freedom of speech and the press, in an edition based upon Sir Richard Jebb’s lectures at Cambridge in 1872, with extensive notes and commentaries. Mlton’s work was a protest against Parliament’s…

THE READING ROOM

Areopagitica: Milton on the Tyranny of Licensing Books

By: Caroline Breashears

In 1638, John Milton left England for a Grand Tour of Europe, traveling through cities such as Paris, Nice, and Genoa. In Florence, he writes, "I found and visited the famous Galileo grown old, a prisoner to the Inquisition, for…

Banned Books

Many of the works in the Online Library of Liberty have been banned or censored at various times by governments, established churches, and pubic schools for their content. Among these are:

a number of translations of the Bible the…

THE READING ROOM

Banning Shylock

By: Carol McNamara

“One would have to be blind, deaf, and dumb not to recognize that Shakespeare’s grand, equivocal comedy, The Merchant of Venice, is a profoundly anti-Semitic work.” This is the pronouncement with which Shakespeare scholar, Harold…
The Barber of Seville, or the Useless Precaution

Pierre-Augustin Caron de Beaumarchais (author)

The first of 3 plays Beaumarchais wrote about a master-servant relationship, Count Almaviva and Figaro, during the social upheavals on the eve of the French revolution.

THE READING ROOM

Beaumarchais and “The Barber of Seville”

By: Gary McGath

If people today have heard of Pierre Augustin Caron de Beaumarchais, it’s usually as the author of the source material for two famous operas, Rossini’s The Barber of Seville and Mozart’s The Marriage of Figaro. He deserves to be far…
Candide, ou l’Optimisme; traduit de l’Allemand de M. le Docteur Ralph

Voltaire (author)

Voltaire’s “philosophic tale” is a clever satire of France in the mid-18th century. He makes fun of religious intolerance, the destructiveness of war, and the foibles of mankind. He concludes with a plea that we should all “cultivate…

THE READING ROOM

Character Description in the Prologue: Chaucer’s Challenge and Threat to England’s Religious

By: Nathaniel Birzer

That Chaucer’s The Canterbury Tales has suffered periods of censorship and banning since its first publication should be of little surprise to anyone who has read any of it. Banned in the latter half of the 19th century in America…
The Chief Works of Benedict de Spinoza, vol 1

Benedict de Spinoza (author)

This volume contains 2 of Spinoza’s most important political works, the Theologico-Political Treatise and the posthumous Political Treatise.

The Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, Volume II - The Principles of Political Economy I

John Stuart Mill (author)

Vol. 2 of the 33 vol. Collected Works contains Part 1 of Mill’s Principles of Political Economy.

The Colloquies 2 vols.

Desiderius Erasmus (author)

In the guise of a school textbook on sound Latin prose Erasmus is able to mix sound language teaching, homilies on Christian ethics, and social criticism of some of the injustices and follies of his day.

The Complaint of Peace

Desiderius Erasmus (author)

The Reformation scholar Desiderius Erasmus portrays Peace visiting to earth to deliver her verdict on the human race. She chastises kings and princes, church leaders, noblemen and ordinary soldiers alike for betraying their Christian…

The Merchant of Venice

William Shakespeare (author)

The Merchant of Venice famously depicts the bargain between Antonio and Shylock to secure a monetary loan with the promise of “a pound of flesh” if the loan is not repaid. In doing so, it explores the complex issues of religion,…

Twelfth-Night: or, What You Will

William Shakespeare (author)

Complicated, merry, and slightly mad, the convoluted disguises and secret identities of Twelfth Night capture the pains and comic madness of love. This edition comes from the 1916 Oxford University Press edition of all of Shakespeare…

Macbeth

William Shakespeare (author)

Shakespeare’s Macbeth explores questions of fate, free will, and tyranny. This edition comes from the 1916 Oxford University Press edition of all of Shakespeare’s plays and poems.

King Lear

William Shakespeare (author)

Shakespeare’s King Lear may be his greatest tragedy. It presents a dark picture of aging, of an uncaring universe, and the dangers of an unstable king struggling to understand his own power. This edition comes from the 1916 Oxford…

The Complete Works of Geoffrey Chaucer, vol. 4 (The Canterbury Tales)

Geoffrey Chaucer (author)

The late 19th century Skeat edition with copious scholarly notes and a good introduction to the text. The Tales are in their original Middle English.

Complete Works, vol. 3

Charles Louis de Secondat, Baron de Montesquieu (author)

This is volume 3 from the Complete Works. It contains his piece on the Grandeur and Declension of the Roman Empire, a short Dialogue between Sylla and Eucrates, and the Persian Letters.

Critique of Pure Reason

Immanuel Kant (author)

One of Kant’s most important philosophical works and one of the most important of the Enlightenment as well. In it he argues that the world that we know is structured by the way that we perceive and think about the world. Reason is…

THE READING ROOM

David Hume’s Great Work on Religion Is Banned, Along with All His Books

By: Walter Donway

The Christian religion not only was at first attended with miracles, but even at this day cannot be believed by any reasonable person without one.—David HumeThe life of man is of no greater importance to the universe than that of an…
The Divine Comedy, in 3 vols. (Langdon trans.)

Dante Alighieri (author)

Dante’s masterwork is a 3 volume work written in Italian rather than Latin. Vol. 1 (Inferno (Hell) describes what happens to the souls of the wicked who are condemned to suffer the torments of Hell. Vol. 2 Purgatorio (Purgatory)…

THE READING ROOM

“Don’t be such a Machiavel.” Actually, do.

By: Lucie Alden

When I told a friend I had been charged with writing an article on Machiavelli for “banned books” week, he retorted: “Machiavelli? Are we banning Machiavelli now?” I was actually rather surprised he was surprised by a ban on…
The English Works, vol. X (Iliad and Odyssey)

Homer (author)

Hobbes’s translation of Homer’s epic poems the Iliad and the Odyssey. The Iliad is about the warriors and heroes who are involved in the Trojan war, what happens to men in combat, and the consequences of pride, ambition, and failure.…

Enquiries Concerning the Human Understanding and Concerning the Principles of Morals

David Hume (author)

Two of David Hume’s most important works of moral philosophy, epistemology, and psychology which together were supposed to make up Hume’s “science of man”. They are a revised version of his earlier work A Treatise of Human Nature

Essays of Montaigne, in 10 vols.

Michel de Montaigne (author)

This is a 10 volume collection of Montaigne’s famous essays in the 17th century English translation by Charles Cotton.

The Historical, Political, and Diplomatic Writings, vol. 2

Niccolo Machiavelli (author)

Volume 2 of a 4 volume set of Machiavelli’s writings which contains a lengthy introduction on the life of Machiavelli, the History of Florence, The Prince, Discourses on Livy, and his letters and papers from his time as a diplomat.…

The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, 12 vols.

Edward Gibbon (author)

A 12 volume set of Gibbon’s magisterial history of the end of the Roman Empire, one of the greatest works of history written during the Enlightenment.

The Holy Qur-an (Koran) (Arabic and English)

Muhammad (author)

Tradition holds that during the last decades of Muhammad’s life he received revelations from the angel Gabriel. Muhammad was instructed to repeat these revelations to his community as warnings or instructions from God. During his…

THE READING ROOM

How a liberal Constitution became a forbidden book

By: Alberto Mingardi

The old world ended with a bang, not with a whimper. After the Bastille, no political thinker could escape the haunting ghost of the French Revolution - and indeed students of politics still cannot. Antonio Rosmini (1787-1855) was…

THE READING ROOM

How Homer Foretold the Perils of Big Government

By: Vance Ginn

In the tapestry of human history, one recurring thread stands out – the need for limited power in leadership.

THE READING ROOM

Hume on Love of Glory, not Usury

By: Eric Schliesser

It’s probably not a major surprise that prompted by the first three volumes of the Italian translation of Hume’s History of England, the Vatican placed all of Hume’s writings on the Index Librorum prohibitorum in 1827. [1] After…
Ideal Empires and Republics

Sir Francis Bacon (author)

A collection of 4 of the best known works about utopias: Rousseau’s Social Contract, More’s Utopia, Bacon’s New Atlantis, and Campanella’s City of the Sun.

In Praise of Folly

Desiderius Erasmus (author)

The personification of Folly comes to earth to expose the follies, foibles, and failings of humans. Illustrated with 77 woodcuts by Hans Holbein.

The Institutes of the Christian Religion

John Calvin (author)

in 1535 John Calvin published the initial version of the Institutes. The importance of the Institutes lies with its inclusive and systematic explication of Protestant doctrine. It forcefully presents the Protestants’ claim to teach…

THE READING ROOM

John Stuart Mill on Lighthouses

By: Rosolino A. Candela

The limits of laissez-faire as a principle by which to limit the role of the government in a market economy has never been without controversy. Among the biggest “hotspots” that is representative of this controversy, still debated…

THE READING ROOM

John Stuart Mill on Say’s Law

By: Rosolino A. Candela

One of the most important and controversial principles originating from classical economics is the principle known as “Say’s Law,” or the fundamental law of markets. Although this economic principle can trace its roots back to Adam…

THE READING ROOM

Justice in Hell and Liberal Rationales of Punishment

By: John Alcorn

Dante plumbs the depths of the human condition by recounting his existential journey through hell, purgatory, and paradise; a journey punctuated by poignant encounters with myriad souls. His journey is impelled by a midlife crisis…

THE READING ROOM

Law and its Development in the Talmud

By: Steven Grosby

If one were to reduce the numerous works of the three thousand year-long, still developing Jewish tradition to those books constitutive of that tradition, there would, by general agreement, be three. The first is the Hebrew Bible,…

THE READING ROOM

Lear: a King and Play in Exile

By: Lucie Alden

King Lear is a graphic, grotesque, visceral play. Blow after blow strikes Lear and the audience as we see a great man transformed from King of England to homeless, mad wretch, worse than the blind Gloucester and the raving Poor Tom.…
Leviathan (1909 ed)

Thomas Hobbes (author)

The 1909 edition of Hobbe’s best known work of political philosophy is the edition used by Michael Oakeshott in his discussion of Hobbe’s ideas in Hobbes on Civil Association (1937, 1975 Liberty Fund).

The Manual of a Christian Knight

Desiderius Erasmus (author)

Erasmus’s very popular 16th century guide book on how to live a moral, Christian life while avoiding formal ritual and observances.

The Marriage of Figaro (or the Follies of a Day)

Pierre-Augustin Caron de Beaumarchais (author)

The second of 3 plays Beaumarchais wrote about a master-servant relationship, Count Almaviva and Figaro, during the social upheavals on the eve of the French revolution. In this play they become rivals for the affections of Suzanne.

The Method, Meditations and Philosophy of Descartes

René Descartes (author)

A collection of three of Descatres philosophical works: the Discourse of Method, the Meditations, and selections from his Principles of Philosophy.

The Natural History of Religion

David Hume (author)

In The Natural History of Religion and in the Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion Hume provides a sustained philosophical and historical analysis of religion.

THE READING ROOM

Nicolas de Condorcet’s Sketch of Unlimited Human Progress—Published 1801, Banned Worldwide 1827

By: Walter Donway

It was a tiny room in the home of Madame Vernet on rue Servandoni in Paris. Marquis Nicolas de Condorcet sat writing by candlelight, the candle shaded for added security. He was writing a fragment of a much longer piece eventually…
Novum Organum

Sir Francis Bacon (author)

Part of a larger but incomplete magnum opus in which Bacon demonstrates the use of the scientific method to discover knowledge about the natural world. Many of the examples in this volume concern the nature of heat and energy.

THE READING ROOM

Obfuscating John Milton’s Paradise Lost

By: David V. Urban

As Caroline Breashears has recently discussed, John Milton (1608-74) was a prominent champion of the freedom of the press, something he most famously exhibited in his 1644 tract Areopagitica. But Milton’s own writings were and…

THE READING ROOM

Outlines of an historical view of the progress of the human mind

Marie-Jean-Antoine-Nicolas Caritat, Marquis de Condorcet (author)

Condorcet wrote this while in prison awaiting execution by the Jacobins. It is an optimistic view of the progress the human race will undergo when political and economic liberty are gradually introduced.

THE READING ROOM

“Out, damned spot.” Out Shakespeare.

By: Lucie Alden

When it comes to why Thomas Bowdler felt the need to “censor” Shakespeare’s Macbeth in 1807, the answer is pretty easy: it features a lady cursing.

THE READING ROOM

Paradise Lost, Perhaps the Greatest English Poem. Banned for 216 Years

By: Walter Donway

Paradise Lost, published more than 350 years ago (1667), is still almost routinely characterized as the greatest poem in English. More guardedly, it is called “the greatest epic poem.” (Yes, there are others, such as Beowulf,…
Philosophical Works of David Hume

David Hume (author)

Vol. 1 - Treatise of Human Nature Bk 1; Vol. 2 - Treatise of Human Nature Bk 2 and 3; Vol. 3 - Essays Moral, Political and Literary; Vol. 4 An Inquiry Concerning the Human Understanding, An Inquiry Concerning the Principles of…

The Poetical Works of John Milton

John Milton (author)

A modern edition of the major poems of Milton. It contains the shorter poems, Paradise Lost and Regained, and Samson Agonistes.

Principles of Political Economy (Ashley ed.)

John Stuart Mill (author)

Principles of Political Economy, with some of their Applications to Social Philosophy was published in 1848 in London and was republished with changes and updates a total of seven times in Mill’s lifetime. The edition presented here…

THE READING ROOM

Reflecting on Banned Books: Hume’s Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding

By: Aeon J. Skoble

Britain, 1761. All of David Hume’s works are banned by the Index Librorum Prohibitorum, including his 1748 Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding. What was so horrible about the work of this Scottish philosopher that would make the…

THE READING ROOM

Rousseau’s Discourse on the Arts and Sciences

By: Philip D. Bunn

Rousseau’s life was marked and marred by controversy and persecution. Though his lifestyle was somewhat sordid, as recounted in his Confessions, it was his ideas that were treated as most dangerous by his contemporary intellectual…
The Social Contract and Discourses

G.D.H. Cole (editor)

This 1913 edition of Rousseau’s works includes the famous Social Contract as well as 3 discourses on Arts and Sciences, the Origin of Inequality, and Political Economy. Rousseau’s writings inspired liberals and non-liberals alike…

THE READING ROOM

The Analects: A Target of Tyrants for Two Thousand Years

By: Peter Carl Mentzel

Banned Books Week runs from October 1-7. Because the OLL supports wide access to knowledge, informed readers, and challenging questions, we'll be dedicating the entire month of October to blog posts about books that have been…

THE READING ROOM

The Banning of the Bard

By: Gary McGath

William Shakespeare’s plays have been performed in many ways. They’ve been translated into nearly every language on Earth and at least one “alien” language (Klingon). Sometimes they have undergone serious changes. Legal requirements…

THE READING ROOM

The Complaint of Peace

By: James Hartley

“As Peace, am I not praised by both men and gods as the very source and defender of all good things?...Though nothing is more odious to God and harmful to man, yet it is incredible to see the tremendous expenditure of work and…

THE READING ROOM

The Continuing Story of the Banning and Censoring of the Bible

By: David V. Urban

The banning and censoring of the Bible has a long and multifaceted history that continues to this day, and although it is not typically included within popular lists of banned books, it is safe to assert that the Bible is the most…

THE READING ROOM

The Holy Qur'an

By: Steve Ealy

In the twentieth century, a few communist or socialist governments banned or restricted access to the Qur’an. After the Russian Revolution, the Soviet Union restricted access to the Qur’an along with the Christian Gospels and Jewish…

THE READING ROOM

The Knight’s Tale and its Critics: Chaucer’s Response to Boethius’ Consolation of Philosophy

By: Nathaniel Birzer

At the heart of Chaucer’s The Canterbury Tales lies the Challenge, the thing which draws out the innermost being of each of the characters, revealing a piece of their souls to their fellow pilgrims and sparking the wide-ranging…

THE READING ROOM

The Marriage of Figaro: Banned in France

By: Gary McGath

“So it will never be performed?” said the queen. “Certainly not,” said Louis XVI. “You may be sure of that.”

THE READING ROOM

The Praise of Folly

By: James Hartley

“If someone should attempt to take off the masks and costumes of the actors in a play and show to the audience their real appearances, would he not ruin the whole play?… For what else is the life of man but a kind of play in which…

THE READING ROOM

The Self & Sympathy: David Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature

By: John Alcorn

David Hume conceives the mind in metaphors. The mind is a theater, a republic, a stringed instrument. These metaphors suggest that an individual has multiple selves, whose relations resemble social interactions.

THE READING ROOM

Thomas Hobbes: Leviathan

By: Alice Temnick

Life was nasty, brutish and short. Many of us recall these famous words from Thomas Hobbes’ political treatise, Leviathan (1651). Fewer of us remember the context in which he described this state of humanity.
A Treatise of Human Nature

Lewis Amherst Selby-Bigge (editor)

Hume’s first major work of philosophy published in 1739 when he was just 29 yeas old. It is made up of three books entitled “Of the Understanding”, “Of the Passions”, and “Of Morals”. In the book he uses his sceptical rationalism to…

THE READING ROOM

What if everyone did that? Immanuel Kant, Groundwork of the Metaphysic of Ethics (1785)

By: John Alcorn

“The categorical imperative is therefore single and one: ‘Act from that maxim only which thou canst will law universal.’”—Immanuel Kant, Groundwork, Chapter II
The Works, vol. 1 An Essay concerning Human Understanding Part 1

John Locke (author)

The first part of Locke’s most important work of philosophy. Continued in volume 2.

The Works of Voltaire, Vol. I (Candide)

Voltaire (author)

Taken from the 21 volume 1901 edition of the Complete Works, this is Voltaire’s most famous “philosophic tale” in which he makes fun of the idea that “this is the best of all possible worlds” by showing how much injustice and folly…

The Works of Voltaire, Vol. XIX (Philosophical Letters)

William F. Fleming (translator)

Taken from the 21 volume 1901 edition of the Complete Works, this is an early work by Voltaire of social and political analysis. Forced to go into exile in England, he was very impressed with the practice of religious toleration he…

The Writings of Thomas Paine, Vol. II (1779-1792)

Thomas Paine (author)

Vol. 2 of a 4 vol. collection of the works of Thomas Paine. Vol. 2 (1779-1792) contains the Letter to Abbey Raynal, Dissertations on Government, The Rights of Man (1 and 2) and various articles.

The Writings of Thomas Paine, Vol. IV (1791-1804)

Thomas Paine (author)

Vol. 4 of a 4 vol. collection of the works of Thomas Paine. Vol. 4 (1791-1804) contains The Age of Reason and various appendices.

Loading...

Quotes

Philosophy

Thomas Hobbes sings a hymn of praise for Reason as “the pace”, scientific knowledge is “the way”, and the benefit of mankind is “the end” (1651)

Thomas Hobbes

Literature & Music

Voltaire in Candide says that “tending one’s own garden” is not only a private activity but also productive (1759)

Voltaire

Philosophy

Voltaire lampooned the excessively optimistic Leibnitzian philosophers in his philosophic tale Candide by exposing his characters to one disaster after another, like a tsunami in Lisbon, to show that this was not “the best of all possible worlds”

Voltaire