The Webster-Hayne Debate on the Nature of the Constitution: Selected Documents
The debates between Daniel Webster of Massachusetts and Robert Hayne of South Carolina gave fateful utterance to the differing understandings of the nature of the American Union that had come to predominate in the North and the South, respectively, by 1830. To Webster the Union was the indivisible expression of one nation of people. To Hayne the Union was the voluntary compact among sovereign states. Each man spoke more or less for his section, and their classic expositions of their respective views framed the political conflicts that culminated at last in the secession of the Southern states and war between advocates of Union and champions of Confederacy. The Webster-Hayne Debate consists of speeches delivered in the United States Senate in January of 1830. By no means were Webster and Hayne the only Senators who engaged in debate “on the nature of the Union.” Well over a score of the Senate’s members spoke in response in sixty-five speeches all told, and these Senators did not merely echo either of the principals. The key speakers and viewpoints are included in The Webster-Hayne Debate. The volume opens with Hayne’s speech, which, as Herman Belz observes, turned debates on “the public lands” into “a clash between state sovereignty and national sovereignty, expounded as rival and irreconcilable theories of constitutional construction and the nature of the federal Union.” Webster responded, Hayne retorted, and Webster concluded with an appeal to “Liberty and Union, now and forever, one and inseparable,” in what later historians would deem to be “the most powerful and effective speech ever given in an American legislature.” Other speeches in the volume are by Senators Thomas Hart Benton, John Rowan, William Smith, John M. Clayton, and Edward Livingston. Together, these speeches represent every major perspective on “the nature of the Union” in the early nineteenth century.
Read the Liberty Classic on this title from Law & Liberty
The Webster-Hayne Debate on the Nature of the Constitution: Selected Documents, ed. Herman Belz (Indianapolis: Liberty Fund, 2000).
The copyright to this edition, in both print and electronic forms, is held by Liberty Fund, Inc.
|HTML||This version has been converted from the original text. Every effort has been taken to translate the unique features of the printed book into the HTML medium.||1.44 MB|
|LF Printer PDF||This text-based PDF was prepared by the typesetters of the LF book.||2.02 MB|
|MARC Record||MAchine-Readable Cataloging record.||1.74 KB|
Table of Contents
- Note on the Text
- The Webster-Hayne Debate on the Nature of the Union
- Robert Y. Hayne
- Speech of Mr. Hayne, of South Carolina [January 19, 1830]
- Daniel Webster
- Speech of Mr. Webster, of Massachusetts [January 20, 1830]
- Speech of Mr. Hayne, of South Carolina [January 25, 1830]
- Speech of Mr. Webster, of Massachusetts [January 26 and 27, 1830]
- Note 1.: Wednesday, February 21, 1787.
- Note 2.: Extracts from Mr. Calhoun’s Speech, on Mr. Randolph’s motion to strike out the minimum valuation on Cotton Goods, in the House of Representatives, April, 1816.
- Extracts from the Speech of Mr. Calhoun, April, 1816—On the Direct Tax.
- Note 3.
- VIRGINIA LEGISLATURE. Extract from the Message of Gov. Tyler, of Virginia, Dec. 4, 1809.
- House of Delegates —Friday, December 15, 1809.
- Thursday, January 11, 1810.
- Tuesday, January 23, 1810.
- In Senate —Wednesday, January 24, 1810.
- Friday, January 26.
- Mr. Webster’s Last Remarks.
- Speech of Mr. Hayne, of South Carolina [January 27, 1830]
- Thomas Hart Benton
- Speech of Mr. Benton, of Missouri [January 20 and 29, February 1 and 2, 1830]
- THE LETTER.
- “Journals of Congress, vol. 4, p. 654.”
- January 29, 1830.—Second Day.
- The Message—Extract.
- The Journal. “Wednesday, January 12th, 1803.
- February 1, 1830. Third Day.
- The Speech—An Extract.
- February 2, 1830.—Fourth Day.
- The Charge—Extract.
- THE CONTRAST.
- John Rowan
- Speech of Mr. Rowan, of Kentucky [February 4, 1830]
- William Smith
- Speech of Mr. Smith, of South Carolina [February 25, 1830]
- John M. Clayton
- Speech of Mr. Clayton, of Delaware [March 4, 1830]
- Speech of Mr. Livingston, of Louisiana [March 9, 1830]
- A Note on the Type