Monuments to Two 19th Century Free Traders: Frédéric Bastiat (1801-1850) & Richard Cobden (1804-1865)
Introduction
Many statues and monuments are erected in public places to military leaders,
kings, emperors, and presidents who take their countries to war, raise taxes,
increase economic regulation of the economy, and violate civil liberties. Far
fewer are the monuments to people who actually increase the sphere of liberty
in which individuals can run their lives and businesses. We have two examples
of the latter here: two men who agitated for and eventually helped create the
conditions for expanded free trade among the people of Europe in the mid-19th
century - Richard Cobden (1804-1865) and Frédéric Bastiat (1801-1850). Richard
Cobden began the process by forming the Anti-Corn Law League in Britain in
1838 in the manufacturing city of Manchester in order to eliminate the tariffs
and price controls on imported "corn ( i.e. wheat) which was the main
staple for working class Britishers. Using innovative techniques to mobilize
public opinion in favour of repealing the
"corn laws", as they were known, Cobden and the Anti-Corn Law
League were able to put sufficient pressure on the British government
to force their repeal in 1846. Cobden's success inspired the Frenchman
Frédéric Bastiat to emulate his tactics by starting a free trade movement
in France. Bastiat initially failed to organize the French people as
Cobden had done with his Société de la liberté d'échange but he went
on to develop some of the best articles and books in favour of free trade
ever penned before his untimely death in 1850. The culmination of both
their lives' work came in 1860 when Cobden and the French politician
Michel Chevalier signed the Anglo-French Treaty of Commerce in 1860 ushering
in a period of relative free trade in Europe which lasted until the 1890s
when tariff wars between the major European powers again broke out. Without
resorting to tax-payer funded financial support, the admirers of Cobden
and Bastiat raised money privately and independently of each other in
order to build monuments to these pioneers of the free trade movement.
The Society of Political Economy in France and private citizens who
supported Cobden in Britain raised money to design, build, and erect
statues to these men. Bastiat's was erected in his home town of Mugron
in S.W. France; Cobden had statues of him erected in his home town of
Manchester as well as in London (which we show here). In addition their
supporters created busts and medals in order to celebrate their lives
and careers. As the motto on Cobden's commemorative medal states let there
be "Free Trade, Peace, Goodwill among Nations".
Note that Liberty Fund will be publishing the Collected Works of Frédéric Bastiat beginning in March 2011.
Online Resources
Monuments to two 19th Century Free Traders: Frédéric Bastiat
(1801-1850)
& Richard Cobden (1804-1865)
|
|
|
|
Gabriel-Vital Dubray, "Frédéric Bastiat"
(1878)
|
W. and T. Wills, "Cobden" (1868)
|
A monument erected in memory of the French
free trade advocate Frédéric Bastiat (1801-1850) in the town of Mugron
in S.W. France (1878). The sculptor was Gabriel-Vital
Dubray (1813-1892).
The original monument was largely destroyed by the Nazis in 1942. A contemporary
engraving shows what it looked like [see below].
|
A statue erected in memory of the English
free tradeadvocate Richard Cobden (1804-1865) in Camden Town, London
(1868). The sculptors were W. and T. Wills.
|
|
|
|
|
The plaque lists the works for which
Bastiat was best remembered. The top three were part of the original
monument: Cobden
and the League (1845),
Economic Sophisms (1845, 1848), Economic Harmonies (1850); the fourth
titleThe
Law (1850) was added in 2001 for the bicentennial celebration
of his birth. It also states that "This
Monument was inaugurated April 23, 1878." What it does not
say is that it too was erected by public subscription organized
by the Société d'économie politique.
|
The plaques states that the statue was
"erected by public subscription, to which Napoleon III was
principal contributor. Presented to the vestry of St. Pancras,
June 1868. Thomas Ross, chairman of committee."
|
|
|
|
|
A picture of Frédéric Bastiat (1801-1850)
|
A picture of Richard Cobden (1804-1865)
|
|
|
|
|
At the insistence of his aunt, Bastiat
consented to have a bust made in 1849. It was done by M. Henri
Sobre fils. and copies were made for many of his friends, including
Richard Cobden. It is likely that the 1849 version was used as
the model for Dubray's likeness on the monument. The image shown
here is from the monument. There is no known copy of the original
1849 version.
|
A bust made of Cobden, probably after
his death.
|
|
|
|
|
A medal with the likeness of Bastiat
was made by the Société d'économie politique in 1892 to celebrate
the 50th anniversary of its founding. We have not yet been able
to find a picture of it.
|
A medal made to celebrate Richard Cobden:
obverse has the head of Cobden; reverse has the motto "Free Trade,
Peace, Goodwill among Nations", the statement "Cobden Club
founded 1866, and a wreath of ears of wheat (or "corn") (after
1866).
|
|
|
|
Gabriel-Vital Dubray, "Frédéric
Bastiat"
(1878)
|
|
This engraving from the magazine Le Monde illustré appeared
shortly after the inauguration of the monument in Mugron on 23 April
1878 and accompanied a report of the event. The well-knpwn sculptor
Gabriel-Vital Dubray (1813-1892) had been commissioned to design
and create the monument. Dubray was a very successful sculptor who
had created many important works during the Third Empire (1852-1870)
for which he was made a knight of the Legion of Honor.
Many of his works were displayed in churches and even in the Louvre
Palace.Thus it was quite a coup to get an artist of his stature
and importance to do the Bastiat monument. As the engraving above
indicates, Dubray planned an elaborate monument with the classical
figure of "Fame" leaning against the pedestal and writing with her
pen the titles of the three books for which Bastiat was best remembered
and for which he deserved to be famous: the
work in which he first introduced the French to the ideas on free
trade of Richard Cobden and the Anti-Corn Law League Cobden
and the League (1845), his best selling collection of witty
and clever articles debunking the economic myths of the protectionists Economic
Sophisms (1845,
1848), and his incomplete magnum opus on economic theory Economic
Harmonies (1850).
It seems that nature did not smile upon Bastiat's monument on
that occasion as it rained for most of the day. This did not stop
numerous speakers including Léon Say, the Minister of Finance,
from reminding the crowd of well wishers of Bastiat's importance
to the classical liberal movement in France and his contributions
to the deregulation
of the French economy. At 7.00 pm a crowd of 150 gathered in
the local school for a banquet which lasted until 11.00 pm when
they dispersed. But they did not retire to bed apparently. The
correspondent for the Journal des économistes remarked
wryly that "the streets of Mugron were full of singing and noise
for the rest of the night" thus bringing to an end a veritable
"festival of peace."
Unfortunately this festival of peace did not survive the orgies
of statism and nationalism which were the First and Second World
Wars. M. Jacques de Guenin, the director of the Cercle Frédéric
Bastiat in France states
that in 1942 during the occupation of France by the Nazis any statues
containing bronze were to be seized and broken up for their metal
content (presumably to make weapons). This was the unfortunate
fate of the Bastiat monument - the bust of Bastiat and the figure
of Fame were taken for scrap for war matériel. The bust could be
reconstituted after the war because the original mold had survived,
but the figure of Fame was lost forever. It is both sad and ironic
that this would be the fate of Bastiat's monument as Bastiat had
dedicated himself to the cause of peace and opposition to war as
his writings and his participation in the Peace Congresses of the
late 1840s attest.
However, one might say that "Fame" did eventaully return to Bastiat's
monument
in spite of what the Nazis and 50 years of the European welfare
state had done to it. Bicentennial
celebrations of Bastiat's birth were organised in 2001, including
a major conference on his political and economic ideas and a formal
visit to his monument in Mugron to unveil an addition to the list
of his most famous works. The title of the pamphlet "La Loi" (The
Law) was added in respect to the many American visitors who hold
this work of Bastiat's in high regard. "Fame" had at last been
recalled to complete the work which she had begun in 1878.
|
Sources for the images:
Bastiat: the Cercle Frédéric Bastiat website <http://bastiat.net/fr/images.html>
Cobden: public domain images from Wikipedia
& other sources
|