|
|
Front Page  Titles (by Subject) 91.: Procedure in the House: Amendments 21 APRIL, 1868 - The Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, Volume XXVIII The Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, Volume XXVIII - Public and Parliamentary Speeches Part I November 1850 - November 1868
91.: Procedure in the House: Amendments 21 APRIL, 1868 - John Stuart Mill, The Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, Volume XXVIII The Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, Volume XXVIII - Public and Parliamentary Speeches Part I November 1850 - November 1868 [1850]Edition used:The Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, Volume XXVIII - Public and Parliamentary Speeches Part I November 1850 - November 1868, ed. John M. Robson and Bruce L. Kinzer (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1988).
About Liberty Fund:Liberty Fund, Inc. is a private, educational foundation established to encourage the study of the ideal of a society of free and responsible individuals. Copyright information:The online edition of the Collected Works is published under licence from the copyright holder, The University of Toronto Press. ©2006 The University of Toronto Press. All rights reserved. No part of this material may be reproduced in any form or medium without the permission of The University of Toronto Press.
Fair use statement:
This material is put online to further the educational goals of Liberty Fund, Inc. Unless otherwise stated in the Copyright Information section above, this material may be used freely for educational and academic purposes. It may not be used in any way for profit.
- Introduction
- Textual Introduction
- Public and Parliamentary Speeches 1850–1873
- November 1850 to July 1865
- 1.: Secular Education After 4 November, 1850?
- 2.: Cooperation 28 March, 1864
- 3.: Corruption At Elections 4 April, 1864
- 4.: Hare’s Plan For the Metropolis 10 April, 1865
- 5.: The Westminster Election of 1865 [1] 3 July, 1865
- 6.: The Westminster Election of 1865 [2] 5 July, 1865
- 7.: The Westminster Election of 1865 [3] 6 July, 1865
- 8.: The Westminster Election of 1865 [4] 8 July, 1865
- 9.: The Westminster Election of 1865 [5] 10 July, 1865
- 10.: The Westminster Election of 1865 [6] 10 July, 1865
- 11.: The Westminster Election of 1865 [7] 12 July, 1865
- February to August 1866:
- 12. The Cattle Diseases Bill [1] 14 February, 1866
- 13.: The Cattle Diseases Bill [2] 16 February, 1866
- 14.: Suspension of Habeas Corpus In Ireland 17 February, 1866
- 15.: Representation of the People [1] 12 April, 1866
- 16.: Representation of the People [2] 13 April, 1866
- 17.: Representation of the People [3] 16 April, 1866
- 18.: The Malt Duty 17 April, 1866
- 19.: Inclosure of Hainault Forest 25 April, 1866
- 20.: Representation of the People [4] 26 April, 1866
- 21.: Chichester Fortescue’s Land Bill 17 May, 1866
- 22.: Representation of the People [5] 31 May, 1866
- 23.: The Ministerial Crisis 23 June, 1866
- 24.: The Jamaica Committee 9 July, 1866
- 25.: Electoral Franchise For Women 17 July, 1866
- 26.: The Disturbances In Jamaica [1] 19 July, 1866
- 27.: The Reform Meeting In Hyde Park [1] 19 July, 1866
- 28.: W.e. Gladstone [1] 21 July, 1866
- 29.: The Reform Meeting In Hyde Park [2] 24 July, 1866
- 30.: The Value of Land 25 July, 1866
- 31.: The Reform Meeting In Hyde Park [3] 26 July, 1866
- 32.: The Reform Meeting In Hyde Park [4] 30 July, 1866
- 33.: The Disturbances In Jamaica [2] 31 July, 1866
- 34.: The Reform Meeting In Hyde Park [5] 2 August, 1866
- 35.: Public Health 2 August, 1866
- 36.: The Extradition Treaties Act [1] 3 August, 1866
- 37.: The Extradition Treaties Act [2] 4 August, 1866
- 38.: The Naval Dockyards 4 August, 1866
- 39.: The Extradition Treaties Act [3] 6 August, 1866
- 40.: The Disturbances In Jamaica [3] 10 August, 1866
- 41.: The Lord Chief Baron 10 August, 1866
- February to August 1867
- 42.: Political Progress 4 February, 1867
- 43.: Goldwin Smith 4 February, 1867
- 44.: The Royal Commission On Trades’ Unions 15 February, 1867
- 45.: The Metropolitan Poor Bill [1] 8 March, 1867
- 46.: The Straits Settlements 8 March, 1867
- 47.: The Metropolitan Poor Bill [2] 8 March, 1867
- 48.: The Metropolitan Poor Bill [3] 11 March, 1867
- 49.: The Metropolitan Poor Bill [4] 14 March, 1867
- 50.: The Reform Bill [1] 8 April, 1867
- 51.: Trades Unions 10 April, 1867
- 52.: The Reform Bill [2] 11 April, 1867
- 53.: The Reform Bill [3] 9 May, 1867
- 54.: The Reform Bill [4] 17 May, 1867
- 55.: The Admission of Women to the Electoral Franchise 20 May, 1867
- 56.: The Municipal Corporations Bill 21 May, 1867
- 57.: The Fenian Convicts 25 May, 1867
- 58.: Reform of Parliament 25 May, 1867
- 59.: The Reform Bill [5] 27 May, 1867
- 60.: Personal Representation 30 May, 1867
- 61.: The Bankruptcy Acts Repeal Bill 4 June, 1867
- 62.: Petition Concerning the Fenians 14 June, 1867
- 63.: The Sunday Lectures Bill 19 June, 1867
- 64.: The Libel Bill 25 June, 1867
- 65.: The Reform Bill [6] 27 June, 1867
- 66.: Redistribution 28 June, 1867
- 67.: William Lloyd Garrison 29 June, 1867
- 68.: Martial Law 2 July, 1867
- 69.: The Reform Bill [7] 4 July, 1867
- 70.: Tancred’s Charity Bill 4 July, 1867
- 71.: The Reform Bill [8] 5 July, 1867
- 72.: The Case of Fulford and Wellstead 5 July, 1867
- 73.: The Reform Bill [9] 15 July, 1867
- 74.: Commodore Wiseman and the Turkish Navy [1] 16 July, 1867
- 75.: Commodore Wiseman and the Turkish Navy [2] 22 July, 1867
- 76.: Meetings In Royal Parks [1] 22 July, 1867
- 77.: Public Education 29 July, 1867
- 78.: The Courts-martial In Jamaica 1 August, 1867
- 79.: Meeting In the Tea-room of the House of Commons 2 August, 1867
- 80.: England’s Danger Through the Suppression of Her Maritime Power 5 August, 1867
- 81.: The Extradition Treaties Act [4] 6 August, 1867
- 82.: The Metropolitan Government Bill 7 August, 1867
- 83.: The Reform Bill [10] 8 August, 1867
- 84.: East India Revenue 12 August, 1867
- 85.: Meetings In Royal Parks [2] 13 August, 1867
- February to November 1868
- 86.: Proportional Representation and Redistribution 29 February, 1868
- 87.: The Alabama Claims 6 March, 1868
- 88.: The State of Ireland 12 March, 1868
- 89.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [1] 26 March, 1868
- 90.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [2] 2 April, 1868
- 91.: Procedure In the House: Amendments 21 April, 1868
- 92.: Capital Punishment 21 April, 1868
- 93.: The Municipal Corporations (metropolis) Bill [1] 5 May, 1868
- 94.: The Established Church In Ireland 7 May, 1868
- 95.: Local Charges On Real Property 12 May, 1868
- 96.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [3] 21 May, 1868
- 97.: Representation of the People (scotland) [1] 28 May, 1868
- 98.: Representation of the People (scotland) [2] 8 June, 1868
- 99.: Married Women’s Property 10 June, 1868
- 100.: Registration of Publication 12 June, 1868
- 101.: Representation of the People (ireland) 15 June, 1868
- 102.: The Government of India Bill [1] 15 June, 1868
- 103.: Lodger Registration 15 June, 1868
- 104.: Public Schools [1] 16 June, 1868
- 105.: The Municipal Corporations (metropolis) Bill [2] 17 June, 1868
- 106.: The Government of India Bill [2] 22 June, 1868
- 107.: Public Schools [2] 23 June, 1868
- 108.: The Sea-fisheries (ireland) Bill 24 June, 1868
- 109.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [4] 25 June, 1868
- 110.: The Municipal Corporations (metropolis) Bill [3] 30 June, 1868
- 111.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [5] 6 July, 1868
- 112.: Public Schools [3] 7 July, 1868
- 113.: Supply—post Office 7 July, 1868
- 114.: The Government of India Bill [3] 8 July, 1868
- 115.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [6] 10 July, 1868
- 116.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [7] 14 July, 1868
- 117.: The Fenian Prisoners [1] 16 July, 1868
- 118.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [8] 17 July, 1868
- 119.: Poor Relief [1] 17 July, 1868
- 120.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [9] 18 July, 1868
- 121.: Imprisonment For Costs On a Dismissed Charge [1] 21 July, 1868
- 122.: The Fenian Prisoners [2] 21 July, 1868
- 123.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [10] 22 July, 1868
- 124.: The Westminster Election of 1868 [1] 22 July, 1868
- 125.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [11] 23 July, 1868
- 126.: Election Petitions and Corrupt Practices At Elections [12] 24 July, 1868
- 127.: Smoking In Railway Carriages [1] 24 July, 1868
- 128.: The Westminster Election of 1868 [2] 24 July, 1868
- 129.: The Metropolitan Foreign Cattle Market 25 July, 1868
- 130.: Smoking In Railway Carriages [2] 25 July, 1868
- 131.: Imprisonment For Costs On a Dismissed Charge [2] 27 July, 1868
- 132.: Poor Relief [2] 27 July, 1868
- 133.: The Westminster Election of 1868 [3] 2 November, 1868
- 134.: The Westminster Election of 1868 [4] 4 November, 1868
- 135.: The Westminster Election of 1868 [5] 6 November, 1868
- 136.: The Westminster Election of 1868 [6] 9 November, 1868
- 137.: Fawcett For Brighton 10 November, 1868
- 138.: The Westminster Election of 1868 [7] 11 November, 1868
- 139.: The Westminster Election of 1868 [8] 13 November, 1868
- 140.: W.e. Gladstone [2] 14 November, 1868
- 141.: The Westminster Election of 1868 [9] 16 November, 1868
- 142.: The Westminster Election of 1868 [10] 18 November, 1868
91.
Procedure in the House: Amendments
21 APRIL, 1868
PD, 3rd ser., Vol. 191, col. 1030. Reported (in one sentence) in The Times, 22 April, p. 6. Mill spoke during an extensive discussion in Committee of Supply on Ayrton’s motion to amend a resolution of the House dating from 1858, “That when it has been proposed to omit or reduce items in a Vote the Question shall be afterwards put upon the original Vote or upon the reduced Vote, as the case may be, without amendment,” by replacing the final two words with “unless an Amendment be moved for a reduction of the whole Vote” (col. 1025). mr. j. stuart mill said, that as it appeared likely that this matter would go back for re-consideration, he might be permitted to suggest a further point. The Motion of his honourable and learned Friend was on a very important and very valuable subject, and formed part of the largest questions. The rules which, in the course of centuries, had been elaborated in this House for the conduct of the Business had been most deservedly admired. But difficulties might arise when the House could only have one Amendment on the same point; because, as soon as one Amendment had been rejected, it had resolved that the original Motion should be put unamended. It might be well for the House to examine this point. According to the rule of the French Chamber, whatever number of Amendments there might be moved, the question of precedency was decided in this way:—The Amendment which was farthest from the original Motion was put first, and if this were lost, the others were put in succession. Might it not be as well to adopt the plan here?
[The matter was resolved by a Government resolution on 28 April that provided for a final vote on the original or amended motion (cols. 1464–6).]
|
