Econlib

The Library

Other Sites

Front Page arrow Titles (by Subject) arrow PURGATORIO XVII - The Divine Comedy, Vol. 2 (Purgatorio) (English only trans.)

Return to Title Page for The Divine Comedy, Vol. 2 (Purgatorio) (English only trans.)

Search this Title:

Also in the Library:

Subject Area: Literature

PURGATORIO XVII - Dante Alighieri, The Divine Comedy, Vol. 2 (Purgatorio) (English only trans.) [1321]

Edition used:

The Divine Comedy of Dante Alighieri. The Italian Text with a Translation in English Blank Verse and a Commentary by Courtney Langdon, vol. 2 (Purgatorio) (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1920).

Part of: The Divine Comedy, in 3 vols. (Langdon trans.)

About Liberty Fund:

Liberty Fund, Inc. is a private, educational foundation established to encourage the study of the ideal of a society of free and responsible individuals.


PURGATORIO XVII

Purgatory. The Third Ring. Anger

Instances of Punished Anger. The Angel of Peace. Love

  • Reader, remind thyself, if e’er a fog
  • o’ertook thee on a mountain, one through which
  • thou couldst not see in any other way
  • than moles do through the membrane o’er their eyes,
  • how, when the damp, thick mists begin to thin,
  • the sun’s orb feebly pierces them; and quickly
  • will thine imagination come to see
  • how I first saw the sun again, which now
  • was at its setting. Thus, as I mine own
  • was matching with my Teacher’s trusty steps,
  • from such a cloud I came into the beams,
  • already dead upon the shores below.
  • O thou Imagination, which at times
  • dost steal us so from outer things, that though
  • a thousand trumpets blow, one hears them not,
  • what moveth thee, if sense contribute naught?
  • A light which takes in Heaven its form impels thee,
  • freely, or by a Will which sends it down.
  • The vision of her cruelty, who changed
  • her form into the bird, which most delights
  • in song, appeared in my imagination;
  • and hereupon my mind was so shut up
  • within itself, that nothing that was then
  • received by it, came to it from without.
  • Then into my high fantasy there rained
  • one crucified, contemptuous and proud
  • in aspect, and as such he met his death.
  • Around him were the great Ahasuerus,
  • Esther his wife, and righteous Mordecai,
  • who so whole-hearted was in word and deed.
  • And as this picture of its own accord
  • broke up, as doth a bubble when it lacks
  • the water it was formed withal; a maid
  • rose in my vision next, who bitterly
  • was weeping, and was saying: “Why, O Queen,
  • didst thou through anger wish to be no more?”
  • Lavinia not to lose, thyself hast slain;
  • and now hast lost me! Mother, this is I,
  • who, ere I mourn another’s loss, mourn thine.”
  • As sleep is broken, when unwonted light
  • strikes closed eyes suddenly, and, being broken,
  • quivers before it wholly dies away;
  • ev’n so did my imagining break up,
  • as soon as on my face there smote a light
  • brighter by far than we are wont to see.
  • I turned around to notice where I was,
  • when lo, a voice which said: “The ascent is here,”
  • from every other interest turned my mind;
  • and made my will so eager to behold
  • the speaker, that, when such, it never rests
  • until it sees its object face to face.
  • But as before the sun, which whelms our eyes,
  • and veils its figure, through excess of light,
  • so likewise here my visual powers failed.
  • “A godlike spirit this, who, though unasked,
  • is pointing out to us our upward path,
  • and with his own light is himself concealing.
  • With us he deals as one would with himself;
  • for he that waits till asked, when seeing need,
  • inclines already meanly to refuse.
  • To such a bidding let us now accord
  • our feet, and try to climb ere darkness come;
  • for later one could not, till day returned.”
  • Thus said my Leader then, and I with him
  • turned toward a flight of stairs our feet; and I,
  • when on its first step, near me felt, as ’t were,
  • the motion of a wing, and on my face
  • a fanning, while a voice said: “Blessèd are
  • the Peaceful, who are free from evil wrath!”
  • So high above us now were those last beams
  • which by the night are followed, that the stars
  • were coming out on many sides. And “O
  • my strength, why dost thou fade away so fast?”
  • I to myself was saying, for a truce,
  • I felt, was set the powers of my legs.
  • We now were where the flight of stairs went up
  • no further, and as motionless we were,
  • as is a vessel when the shore is reached;
  • and for a while I waited to find out
  • if aught upon the new ring could be heard;
  • then, toward my Teacher turning round, I said:
  • “Say, my dear Father, what offense is purged
  • in this ring, here where now we are? Although
  • our feet keep still, let not thy talking cease.”
  • And he to me: “The love of good, when scant
  • of what it should have been, is here atoned;
  • here beats again the ill-retarded oar.
  • But now, in order that thou understand
  • more clearly still, turn thou thy mind to me,
  • and some good fruit thou ’lt gather from our stay.
  • Neither Creator,” he began, “nor creature
  • was e’er devoid of either innate love,
  • or that which conscious is; and this thou knowst.
  • The innate love is always free from error;
  • but the other kind can err through evil aim,
  • or through deficient, or excessive strength.
  • While well directed toward the primal goods,
  • and toward the secondary self-restrained,
  • it cannot be the cause of sinful pleasure;
  • but when it turns toward evil things, or runs
  • to good, with more or less zeal than it ought,
  • the creature then against his Maker works.
  • From this, then, thou canst understand that love
  • must be the seed in you of every virtue,
  • and every deed that merits punishment.
  • And now, since love can never turn its face
  • from its own subject’s welfare, from self-hate
  • all are secure; and since one cannot think
  • of any self as being from the First
  • divided, and existing of itself,
  • all hearts are thus debarred from hating Him.
  • It follows, that, if I in arguing
  • judge well, one’s neighbor’s is the harm one loves,
  • and this is born in three ways in your clay.
  • There ’s he, who on the abasement of his neighbor
  • his hope of rising sets, and only longs
  • that from his greatness he may be brought low;
  • and he, who fears the loss of power, favor,
  • renown and honor, should another rise,
  • and grieves so, that he loves the contrary;
  • then he, who by injustice seems so shamed,
  • that greedy he becometh for revenge;
  • and such must needs prepare for others’ harm.
  • This triform love is wept for here below;
  • but now I ’d have thee hear about the other,
  • which runs to love in a corrupted way.
  • All apprehend confusedly a good
  • wherein the mind can rest, and long for it;
  • and therefore every one attempts to reach it.
  • If slothful be the love impelling you
  • to see or win it, after just repentance,
  • this present cornice tortures you for that.
  • Another good there is, which never makes
  • man happy; it is not real happiness,
  • nor the Good Essence, fruit and root of all
  • that ’s good. The love that yields too much to that,
  • is wept for in three rings above us here;
  • but why it ’s reckoned threefold I say not,
  • that thou mayst seek the reason for thyself.”