Econlib

The Library

Other Sites

Front Page arrow Titles (by Subject) arrow PURGATORIO XVI - The Divine Comedy, Vol. 2 (Purgatorio) (English only trans.)

Return to Title Page for The Divine Comedy, Vol. 2 (Purgatorio) (English only trans.)

Search this Title:

Also in the Library:

Subject Area: Literature

PURGATORIO XVI - Dante Alighieri, The Divine Comedy, Vol. 2 (Purgatorio) (English only trans.) [1321]

Edition used:

The Divine Comedy of Dante Alighieri. The Italian Text with a Translation in English Blank Verse and a Commentary by Courtney Langdon, vol. 2 (Purgatorio) (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1920).

Part of: The Divine Comedy, in 3 vols. (Langdon trans.)

About Liberty Fund:

Liberty Fund, Inc. is a private, educational foundation established to encourage the study of the ideal of a society of free and responsible individuals.


PURGATORIO XVI

Purgatory. The Third Ring. Anger

Free Will and the Corruption of the World

  • The gloom of Hell and of a night deprived
  • of every planet, ’neath a narrow sky,
  • darkened as much as possible by clouds,
  • ne’er made so thick a veil before my face,
  • nor to my feeling was so rough in tissue,
  • as was the smoke which covered us up there;
  • for that permitted not of opened eyes;
  • because of which my wise and trusty Escort
  • drew near to me, and offered me his shoulder.
  • Even as a blind man walks behind his guide,
  • in order not to go astray, and strike
  • aught that might hurt him, or might even kill;
  • so, going through that foul and bitter air,
  • I listened to my Leader, who said only:
  • “Take care that thou be not cut off from me!”
  • Voices I heard, and each appeared to pray
  • for peace and mercy to the Lamb of God,
  • who taketh sins away. Their only prelude
  • was “Lamb of God”; and all had but one word
  • and intonation, hence among them all
  • there seemed to be the fullest harmony.
  • “Are those, then, spirits, Teacher, whom I hear?”
  • said I; and he to me: “Thou judgest rightly;
  • as on they go, they loosen anger’s knot.”
  • “Now who art thou, that cleavest thus our smoke,
  • and yet dost speak of us, as if thou still
  • by monthly calends wert dividing time?”
  • These words were uttered by a single voice;
  • my Teacher therefore said to me: “Reply,
  • and ask him if on this side one goes up.”
  • And I: “O creature, that dost cleanse thyself,
  • that beautiful thou mayst return to Him
  • who made thee, thou’lt hear marvels, following me.”
  • “I ’ll follow thee as far as I ’m allowed,”
  • he answered, “and, if smoke permit not sight,
  • hearing, instead, will keep us linked together.”
  • I thereupon began: “I go on high
  • while in that swathing-band which death dissolves;
  • and through the infernal anguish came I here;
  • and whereas God hath wrapt me in His Grace
  • so much, that He would have me see His court
  • by means entirely out of modern use,
  • conceal not who thou wast before thy death,
  • but tell it me, and whether toward the pass
  • I rightly go; and be thy words our guides.”
  • “Lombard I was, and Marco was I called;
  • familiar with the world, I loved the worth,
  • toward which all men have now unbent their bows.
  • For mounting upward thou art going rightly.”
  • He thus replied, and added: “I beseech thee,
  • pray for me there, when thou shalt be above.”
  • And I to him: “I pledge my faith to thee
  • that what thou askest of me I will do;
  • but with a doubt I ’ll burst, unless therefrom
  • I free myself. Simple at first, it now
  • is doubled by thy speech, which makes me, here
  • and elsewhere, sure of that wherewith I link it.
  • The world is certainly as wholly void
  • of every virtue as thou tellest me,
  • and is with evil big and overspread;
  • but, pray, point out its cause, that I may see,
  • and show it unto other men; for one
  • puts it in heaven, another, here below.”
  • At first he heaved a sigh profound, which grief
  • to “Ah me!” changed; then “Brother,” he began,
  • “the world is blind, and thou, indeed, com’st hence.
  • Ye that are living still attribute upward
  • each cause to heaven alone, as though it moved
  • everything with it of necessity.
  • If this were so, Free Will would be destroyed
  • within you, and no justice would there be
  • in having joy for good, and grief for ill.
  • Heaven starts your inclinations, though I say
  • not all; but ev’n supposing that I did,
  • light has been giv’n to you for good and evil,
  • with Free Will, which, if it endure fatigue
  • in its first fights with heaven, will afterward,
  • if duly nourished, conquer everything.
  • Beneath a greater Power and better Nature
  • ye freely lie; and that creates within you
  • the mind, which heaven hath not in its control.
  • Hence, if the present world go wrong, the cause
  • is in yourselves, and should in you be sought;
  • of this I ’ll now a true spy be for thee.
  • Forth from the hand of Him, who ere it lives
  • delights in it, ev’n like a little maid,
  • who weeps and laughs, and wantons like a child,
  • issues the simple soul, which knoweth nought,
  • save that, proceeding from a Joyous Maker,
  • it gladly turns to that which pleases it.
  • At first it tasteth things of little good;
  • deceived thereby, it runneth after them,
  • unless a guide or check divert its love.
  • Hence, as a bit, a law must needs be set;
  • a king must needs be had, who should at least
  • the tower of the truthful town discern.
  • The laws exist, but who sets hand to them?
  • No one; because the Shepherd who precedes
  • can chew the cud, but hath not cloven hoofs;
  • the people, hence, who see their guide strive solely
  • for those good things for which it longs itself,
  • feedeth thereon, and asks for nothing more.
  • Well canst thou see that evil leadership,
  • and not that Nature in you is corrupt,
  • is what has caused the world to be so wicked.
  • Rome, which once made it good, was wont to have
  • two Suns, which rendered visible both roads,
  • that of the world, and that of God. One now
  • hath quenched the other; to the bishop’s staff
  • the sword is joined, and badly needs must one
  • fare with the other, since, together joined,
  • neither the other fears; recall to mind,
  • if thou believe me not, the ear of corn;
  • for every grass is by its own seed known.
  • Throughout the country watered by the Po
  • and Adige, one used to find both virtue
  • and courtesy, ere Frederick had his strife;
  • with safety it can nowadays be crossed
  • by any who, through shame, refrained from speech
  • with good men, or avoided intercourse.
  • There are, indeed, three old men still, in whom
  • the old age chides the modern, and who long
  • for God to give them back a better life:
  • Corrado da Palazzo, good Gherardo,
  • and Guido da Castello, better called,
  • the simple Lombard, as in France he is.
  • Say, therefore, that today the Church of Rome,
  • by joining in herself two kinds of rule,
  • falls in the mire, and fouls her self and load!”
  • “O Marco mine,” said I, “thine arguments
  • are good; and now I see why Levi’s sons
  • were from inheriting debarred. But which
  • Gherardo is the one, who, as thou sayst,
  • as sample of the people now extinct,
  • remaineth to reproach this savage age?”
  • “Thy speech deceives or tests me,” he replied,
  • “for, thou, addressing me in Tuscan speech,
  • seemst not to know who good Gherardo was.
  • I know him not by other added name,
  • unless I took it from his daughter, Gaia.
  • God keep you, for with you I come no further!
  • Already whitening now, behold the light,
  • which rays out through the smoke, and I must go —
  • the Angel ’s there — ere I be seen by him.”
  • He thus turned back, nor would he hear me more.